The Scotties Tournament of Hearts All-Star Teams are selected by the Canadian Curling Reporters as determined by overall shooting percentages during the Round Robin. In the case of a percentage tie, the player on the higher-ranking team was awarded the all-star position.

First-Team All-Stars

2008
Skip	Shannon Kleibrink, AB	Second	Jill Officer, MB
Third	Amy Nixon, AB	Lead	Chelsey Bell, AB
2007
Skip	Kelly Scott, CAN	Second	Jill Officer, MB
Third	Jeanna Schraeder, CAN	Lead	Marcia Gudereit, SK
2006
Skip	Kelly Scott, BC	Second	Mary-Anne Arsenault, NS
Third	Jeanna Schraeder, BC	Lead	Georgina Wheatcroft, CAN
2005
Skip	Jennifer Jones, MB	Second	Dawn Askin, ON
Third	Marliese Miller, SK	Lead	Nancy Delahunt, CAN
2004
Skip	Colleen Jones, CAN	Second	Maureen Bonar, MB
Third	Amy Nixon, AB	Lead	Nancy Delahunt, CAN
2003
Skip	Colleen Jones, CAN	Second	Robyn MacPhee, PEI
Third	Sherry Linton, SK	Lead	Nancy Delahunt, CAN
2002
Skip	Sherry Anderson, SK	Second	Mary-Anne Waye, CAN
Third	Janet Brown, ON	Lead	Nancy Delahunt, CAN
2001
Skip	Marie-France Larouche, QC	Second	Georgina Wheatcroft, CAN
Third	Kim Kelly, NS	Lead	Sheri Cordina, ON
2000
Skip	Connie Laliberte, MB	Second	Karen Daku, SK
Third	Cathy Overton-Clapham, MB	Lead	Tricia MacGregor, PEI
1999
Skip	Colleen Jones, NS	Second	Brenda Bohmer, CAN
Third	Heather Godberson, CAN	Lead	Lou Ann Henry, PEI
1998
Skip	Cathy Borst, AB	Second	Brenda Bohmer, AB
Third	Jan Betker, CAN	Lead	Marcia Gudereit, CAN
1997
Skip	Sandra Schmirler, SK	Second	Joan McCusker, SK
Third	Jan Betker, SK	Lead	Jane Hooper-Perroud, CAN
1996
Skip	Sherry Scheirich, SK	Second	Tricia MacGregor, PEI
Third	Kim Gellard, ON	Lead	Judy Pendergast, AB
1995
Skip	Rebecca Jean MacPhee, PEI	Second	Joan McCusker, CAN
Third	Kay Montgomery, SK	Lead	Janet Arnott, MB
1994
Skip	Laura Phillips, NL	Second	Joan McCusker, CAN
Third	Jan Betker, CAN	Lead	Kim Kelly, NS
1993
Skip	Sandra Peterson, SK	Second	Patti McKnight, ON
Third	Cathy Cunningham, NL	Lead	Mary-Anne Arsenault, NS
1992
Skip	Lisa Walker, BC	Second	Kim Kelly, NS
Third	Kathy Fahlman, SK	Lead	Karri Willms, CAN
1991
Skip	Julie Sutton, BC	Second	Sheri Stewart, NB
Third	Jackie-Rae Greening, AB	Lead	Cheryl McPherson, CAN
1990
Skip	Heather Rankin, NS	Second	Andrea Lawes, ON
Third	Jackie-Rae Greening, AB	Lead	Lorie Kehler, SK
1989
Skip	Chris More, MB	Second	Diane Alexander, AB
Third	Karen Purdy, MB	Lead	Tracy Kennedy, CAN
1988
Skip	Michelle Schneider, SK	Second	Georgina Hawkes, BC
Third	Cindy Tucker, BC	Lead	Tracy Kennedy, ON
1987
Skip	Kathie Ellwood, MB	Second	Jan Betker, SK
Third	Sandra Schmirler, SK	Lead	Sheila Schneider, SK
1986
Skip	Linda Moore, CAN	Second	Chris Gervais, SK
Third	Kathy McEdwards, ON	Lead	Laurie Carney, CAN
1985
Skip	Susan Seitz, AB	Second	Debbie Jones, BC
Third	Lindsay Sparkes, BC	Lead	Debbgie Herbert, NL
1984
Skip	Connie Laliberte, MB	Second	Chris Gervais, SK
Third	Gillian Thompson, SK	Lead	Laurie Carney, BC
1983
Skip	Shelly Bildfell, Y/NWT	Second	Cathy Caudle, NS
Third	Sharon Horne, NS	Lead	Penny Ryan, AB
1982
Skip	Arleen Day, SK	Second	Donna Cunliffe, BC
Third	Lynne Andrews, MB	Lead	Barbara Jones-Gordon, NS